A review worth reading
Four things make a review useful to the next customer:
| First-hand | The experience is your own, not a friend's or a relative's: a purchase, a hire, a booking or a quote you got, from the past few years or so. |
|---|---|
| Specific | It names what you bought or had done, and answers what the next customer will ask: did the price match the quote, was it on time, how was a problem handled? A fact outweighs an adjective. |
| Fair | It reports what happened and how you were treated. Hold an opinion as strongly as you like; leave the insults out. |
| The right length | At least 40 characters and no more than 3,000. |
What we turn away
Five questions decide it. A review is not published when the answer is the one on the right.
| The question | Turned away if |
|---|---|
| Who wrote it? | Someone employed by, related to or paid by the company or a competitor; someone rewarded for writing it with a discount, a gift, money, a prize-draw entry or anything else; or someone who already reviewed this company in the last 30 days. |
| Who is it about? | A different company, or a manufacturer, marketplace seller or payment provider instead of the company named. |
| What does it contain? | Links, phone numbers or email addresses; the full name or contact details of a staff member; threats, harassment, hate speech, profanity aimed at people, or sexual content. |
| Whose words are they? | Text copied from elsewhere, or generated by AI tools, in place of an account of what happened to you. |
| Does it accuse anyone of a crime? | Then report that to the authorities instead. An account of what happened to you can stay. |
Limits on businesses
Any business may invite its customers to leave a review, all of them alike. It may not:
- Trade anything of value for a review, or for a glowing one only.
- Invite only customers it expects to be pleased, or talk unhappy ones out of reviewing.
- Post reviews of itself or of a rival, directly or through staff, relatives or an agency.
- Lean on a reviewer, by pressure or by threat, to change or withdraw what they wrote.
Behind these rules stands 16 CFR Part 465, the US Federal Trade Commission’s rule on consumer reviews and testimonials. Break one of them to obtain a review, and that review comes down.
Rejections and second looks
Publication waits for a moderator’s reading of every review written on Plumb Line, and each rejection is filed with its reason. To dispute one, write to us with the company’s name and the email address you used; the review will be read again.